Policies
Editorial ethics
The principles of research integrity, transparency and independence that govern each of our publications.
Frameworks
Vaquita Publishing's editorial practices are grounded in the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) on authorship and mandatory disclosures, and the principles of transparency and best practice in open access publishing of the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).
These frameworks apply to all our journals and books. Editors-in-chief, editorial board members, reviewers and authors are all expected to follow them.
Authorship and author responsibilities
Authorship is credited only to people who meet the ICMJE criteria: a substantial contribution to the conception or execution of the work, drafting or critical revision of the content, approval of the final version, and agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
Authors also undertake to:
- submit original work that is neither published nor simultaneously under consideration elsewhere
- cite the work of others correctly and disclose any prior publication that overlaps with their manuscript
- declare all funding sources and relevant relationships
- inform the editorial office without delay of any significant error discovered after submission or publication
Any change to the author list after submission must be justified in writing and approved by all authors concerned. Gift, ghost and honorary authorship are not accepted.
Originality and plagiarism
All manuscripts undergo a similarity check using Turnitin software before being sent for review. A high similarity score, text recycling (self-plagiarism) or uncredited use of others' ideas leads to the manuscript being returned to the author or rejected.
When plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data is found after publication, the correction or retraction procedure described below applies.
Generative artificial intelligence
Generative artificial intelligence tools cannot be credited as authors, since they cannot take scientific responsibility. Authors who use them for writing, translation or analysis must disclose this transparently in the manuscript, naming the tool and its use, and remain solely responsible for the accuracy of the content.
Reviewers and editors must not upload a confidential manuscript to an external artificial intelligence tool.
Research ethics and data
Work involving people, personal data or animals must state the approval of a competent ethics committee, or justify its absence, and the collection of informed consent where required. Data from identifiable individuals cannot be published without explicit consent.
Authors are encouraged to deposit their data and research instruments in a recognized repository and state how to access them, to promote transparency and reproducibility. Recognized reporting standards (PRISMA, STROBE, among others) are required where the study type calls for them.
Peer review
Research articles undergo double-blind review: reviewers do not know the identity of the authors, and authors do not know that of the reviewers. After an initial screening by the editorial office, each manuscript is assigned to reviewers selected for their expertise, who give a reasoned opinion on originality, method, soundness of the results and quality of presentation.
Reviewers undertake to keep the manuscript confidential, not to appropriate its content, to give their opinion constructively and within a reasonable time, and to declare any conflict of interest. A reviewer who feels unable to assess a manuscript objectively must decline.
Conflicts of interest
Authors, reviewers and editors must declare any financial, professional, personal or institutional relationship that could influence, or be seen to influence, their work. An editor with such a relationship to a manuscript withdraws from handling it, and it is reassigned to another editorial board member. Authors' declarations are published with the article.
Editorial independence
Decisions to accept or reject rest exclusively on the scientific quality, originality and relevance of manuscripts. They are made without regard to publication fees or to the nationality, gender, religion, origin or political opinions of the authors.
Publication fees are requested only after definitive acceptance. Use of the additional author services has no bearing on the review of a manuscript.
Corrections and retractions
Vaquita Publishing corrects errors and handles breaches of research integrity following COPE guidelines. Depending on the seriousness of the findings, the editorial office publishes:
- an erratum, where a publishing or production error affects the article
- a correction, where an author error affects interpretation without invalidating the conclusions
- an expression of concern, where an investigation is under way or the available evidence is inconclusive
- a retraction, where the conclusions are invalidated by serious error, fraud or an ethical breach
A retracted article remains accessible, clearly marked as such, to preserve the traceability of the scientific record.
Complaints and appeals
Any author, reviewer or reader may report an ethical concern or file a complaint about the handling of a manuscript, the conduct of an editorial team member, or a published article. Authors whose manuscript was rejected may appeal the decision, setting out specific, documented arguments.
Requests should be sent through the contact form, choosing the category “Reporting an ethical concern” or “Complaints and appeals procedure”. Each request is examined by someone not involved in the original file, handled confidentially, and receives a reasoned reply.